Who Could Replace Neil Dudgeon in Midsomer Murders?

Who Could Replace Neil Dudgeon in Midsomer Murders?

Fans of Midsomer Murders are starting to speculate who could replace Neil Dudgeon, who has played the beloved DCI John Barnaby for years. While there is no official confirmation that Dudgeon plans to leave the show, recent comments have stirred up rumors. Among the actors tipped as potential successors is Only Fools and Horses star Nicholas Lyndhurst, along with other TV favorites like Martin Clunes, Ralf Little, and Kenny Doughty. Could one of these actors step into Barnaby’s shoes if Neil ever decides to call it quits?

Nicholas Lyndhurst: From Only Fools and Horses to DCI Barnaby?

Nicholas Lyndhurst is best known for his role as Rodney in the iconic British sitcom Only Fools and Horses, but he could soon take on a much darker role if he becomes the new lead in Midsomer Murders. Bookmakers have placed him among the favorites, with odds of 20/1, to replace Neil Dudgeon. While Lyndhurst has been keeping busy with new projects in the U.S., including the reboot of Frasier, fans of Midsomer Murders are hopeful he could return to British TV in this beloved crime drama.

Kenny Doughty: The Favorite to Lead Midsomer

According to betting odds from Betway, Kenny Doughty, known for his role in Vera, is currently the favorite to replace Neil Dudgeon. With odds standing at 4/1, many believe Doughty would make a great addition to Midsomer Murders. His performance as DS Aiden Healy in Vera has already won him a loyal fanbase, and his transition to lead detective in Midsomer Murders could be seamless.

Ralf Little: From the Tropics to the Countryside?

Another name that frequently comes up in discussions is Death in Paradise star Ralf Little, who recently left his role as DI Neville Parker. Bookies have given Little odds of 5/1, making him a strong contender. After his surprising departure from Death in Paradise, fans are curious whether he might return to TV in another detective role, this time trading the Caribbean for the English countryside.

Daniel Casey: A Nostalgic Return?

Interestingly, Daniel Casey, who played Gavin Troy in Midsomer Murders, has also been suggested as a possible replacement for Neil Dudgeon. Fans have shared their ideas on social media, with some suggesting that Troy could return to Causton as the main detective. With odds of 6/1, Casey could make a nostalgic comeback that longtime fans would undoubtedly love.

Could John Nettles Return?

Though it’s a long shot, some fans have even speculated about the return of John Nettles, the original DCI Tom Barnaby, who led the show for 14 years. With odds of 80/1, it's unlikely, but the idea of Nettles reprising his role has sparked excitement among fans.

Neil Dudgeon Addresses His Future on Midsomer Murders

While the rumors continue to swirl, Neil Dudgeon has remained tight-lipped about his future on the show. In a recent interview with Radio Times, Dudgeon mentioned that stepping into John Nettles' shoes was no easy task when he first took on the role. "It was hard at the beginning because John had done it for 14 years," he admitted. "If they'd canceled me after one series, that would have been embarrassing!"

Despite these challenges, Dudgeon has grown into the role and become a fan favorite. However, his recent comments about being “canceled” have left some fans wondering whether he might be considering an exit.

Conclusion

With Midsomer Murders continuing to be a staple of British television, fans can rest assured that, even if Neil Dudgeon does eventually leave the show, there are plenty of talented actors ready to step up. Whether it’s a seasoned actor like Nicholas Lyndhurst or a beloved former cast member like Daniel Casey, the future of Midsomer Murders looks bright.

FAQ

Who is the favorite to replace Neil Dudgeon in Midsomer Murders?

According to bookmakers, Kenny Doughty from Vera is currently the favorite to replace Neil Dudgeon, with odds of 4/1.

Is Neil Dudgeon leaving Midsomer Murders?

There is no official confirmation that Neil Dudgeon plans to leave, but rumors have circulated due to recent comments he made in an interview.

Could Ralf Little replace Neil Dudgeon?

Ralf Little, who recently left Death in Paradise, has been tipped as a possible replacement for Neil Dudgeon, with odds of 5/1.

What are the odds of John Nettles returning to Midsomer Murders?

While it’s highly unlikely, some fans have speculated about John Nettles returning to the show. Bookmakers have given him odds of 80/1.

Could Nicholas Lyndhurst join Midsomer Murders?

Nicholas Lyndhurst is among the favorites to replace Neil Dudgeon, with odds of 20/1, but it remains to be seen if he will return to British TV.